Board Thread:Dangan Ronpa game talk/@comment-32329805-20180703040727/@comment-32994909-20180706201643

WolfiZee wrote: So, Wiki Mafia isn't perfect in Balancing. There are several problems with it. SO, after getting permission, i've decided to create this to try and rebalance it.

'''Did you really have to go out of your way to write all the roles, one by one, which do not have an asterik? Why could you just not say ‘All the roles that need an asterik, add an asterik,'''

Suggested Role changes
(Rather boring role)

'''This does need to be removed. I disagree with Raven saying it balances Town. Slightly nerfing overpowered Town roles, or buffing evil roles is a better solution than making a totally useless, pointless role that people who get it would just leave.'''

(UP as tarnation)

It’s in the real game, so our hands are tired.

(Obvious rehash)

'''We are keeping this role, and for those of you who are asking why I removed it only being to ignite once, the answer is because that is a very bland and boring mechanic, the Firebrand will just be a Citizen basically afterward. I added a better balance, check the page for further information.'''

(Pest won't be scared)

I reworked this role so rampaging roles will not harm the haunted target, but will still attack all visitors including the Ghost.

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Not under an Aterisk)

(dies on successful Res)

'''Good. Retributionist is seriously overpowered, and more than deserves this nerf. It’s also good because Retributionist is a Citizen after ressurecting, so might as well just die rather than being an auto-confirmed, extra vote for Town.'''

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Remove independant killing feature, not under an Asterisk)

The whole wiki Mafia version of Ambusher I dislike, I’ll rework that to something better.

(Overall Buff)

Not very useful, quite a boring role which is a nerfed Tracker and Spy’s bug ability which almost never produces a message, this role should be removed.

(Overall Buff)

Perhaps make it so it does need constantly visit the target to appear as them, hence when executed by the Jailor it still appears and its disguised target.

(Change the Roleswapping element)

Role swapping should not occur.

(Overall Buff)

I have a good rework idea for this, I’ll switch it up.

(Boring as tarnation)

'''Yep, this should be removed. It’s like a Mafia Citizen.'''

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Debuff, direct upgrade to Consort)

Agreed.

(Debuff, direct upgrade to Consort)

Agreed.

(Remove independent Killing element)

This is a total hard-counter to protective roles, it needs a sort of nerf.

(Sees names instead of Roles)

'''No, it’s fine the way it is. It’s interesting; not a direct rehash of Lookout.'''

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Buff "drink coffee" action)

'''Why? Drinking coffee would allow you to survive for three whole nights without defense, more than enough time.'''

(Not under an Asterisk)

(Can be doused, but still won't win)

Probably should react to dousings in that case.

(Give Consig result)

Fair enough.

(Replace Basic defense with Scum Autovest, move to )

There’s a lot of problems with this role, a lot of things have no effect when deflected, so it should just be removed altogether,

& (No longer under an Asterisk)

(Give Consig result)

Okay.

(No longer under an Asterisk)

(No longer under an Asterisk)

(No longer under an Asterisk)

(Buff, it's UP compared to the other Coven roles)

I’ll try and buff this.

Others
Split the category in 2; "Neutral Lynching" &. The "Neutral Lynching" will be the, , and hopefully a couple more Lynch-related roles, and will be the "Live to see the  Lose" dump.

'''That is way too confusing, I dislike changing alignments. Adding things to alignments are better.'''

Make all the roles Not under an Asterisk.

Please suggest more ideas.